5 Prices for the Same House: What Buyers Need to Know

September 08, 2025

How Buyers Can Identify True Value Among Multiple Listings

Knowing the list prices is just the starting point. To determine if a house offers good value, consider the following:

1. Compare the Price per Square Metre

Calculate the price per square metre for each listing:

Price per m² = Listing Price ÷ House Size in m²

A lower price per m² often indicates better value. However, remember to check what is included — land, renovations, land size, and location.

2. Review Recent Sales of Similar Properties

Look at comparable sales in the neighborhood over the past three to six months. For example, if similar homes sold for around $700,000 last quarter, a listing at $750,000 might be overpriced, unless there's a feature you value highly.

3. Check Market Trends and Future Potential

Research local market forecasts. Are property values trending upward? Is the area developing? These factors may justify a higher price today if the area has strong growth potential.

4. Understand the Seller’s Motivation

Engage with your real estate agent or conduct your research to learn why the seller is listing. Is there a deadline? Are they open to negotiation? This information can help you decide how much to offer.

5. Consider Additional Costs

Don’t forget about costs beyond the asking price:

  • Stamp duty
  • Legal fees
  • Inspection costs
  • Possible repairs or renovations

Knowing the total cost helps compare options accurately.


The Role of Mortgage Terms in Budgeting

Your mortgage influences how much you can pay and the overall price you should consider. Here’s what you should know:

Understanding Australian Mortgages

  • Interest rates: Fixed (set for a term, e.g., 2 years) or variable (fluctuate with the market).
  • Loan-to-value ratio (LVR): The percentage of the property’s value you borrow. Typically up to 80%, though some lenders accept higher with Lenders Mortgage Insurance (LMI).
  • Lenders Mortgage Insurance (LMI): Protects lenders if you default. Usually required if LVR exceeds 80%.

From Overseas Savings to Australian Home Loans

If you’re converting overseas savings, ensure funds are "genuinely available" and traceable. You may need to show:

  • Source of funds
  • International bank statements
  • Exchange rate documentation

Lenders want proof that your deposits are legal and can cover the deposit and upfront costs.


Tips for International Buyers and First-Time Homeowners

Navigating Australian property prices and mortgage rules can be daunting. Here are some tips:

  • Understand Foreign Investment Rules: The Foreign Investment Review Board (FIRB) limits how many properties non-residents can buy. Make sure you’re eligible and comply with deadlines.
  • Prepare Documentation: Valid ID, proof of income, bank statements, and evidence of deposit sources are essential.
  • Consider Currency Fluctuations: If converting overseas funds, exchange rate changes can impact your budget.
  • Timing Is Key: Market conditions fluctuate; buying during a buyer’s market can offer more room for negotiation.

Case Study: Comparing Two Listings of the Same House

Suppose you find the same house listed twice:

ListingPriceSize (m²)Price per m²Seller motivation
Listing A$720,000200$3,600Motivated, urgent sale
Listing B$750,000200$3,750Testing market, less urgent

While Listing A offers a better price per m², verify other conditions:

  • Condition: Is the house move-in ready?
  • Inclusions: Renovations, appliances?
  • Market context: Are prices trending upward?

Use this information to decide which listing offers better value. Don't focus solely on the price tag.


Final Thoughts: Making an Informed Purchase

Multiple listings of the same property can seem confusing. But understanding the underlying factors helps you make better decisions. Price differences reflect seller motivations, market timing, and property features.

Always do thorough research: compare prices, review recent sales, and assess your financial capacity. Work with experienced agents and mortgage brokers who understand the Australian market and can clarify complexities.

Remember, the goal is to find a property that offers real value for your budget. With patience and due diligence, you'll find the right home at the right price.


"Smart buyers don’t just look at the asking price. They consider market trends, property condition, and future growth potential." — John Smith, Real Estate Expert

Happy house hunting!

Madhu Chaudhuri

Madhu Chaudhuri

Director

With over 20 years of experience as a mortgage broker, Madhu specializes in helping migrants and expats find loans suited to their unique financial situations. Her expertise in navigating complex lending requirements and understanding diverse financial backgrounds has helped countless families achieve their Australian property dreams.

Start Your Finance Journey Today

Book a free 15-minute call and discover your smartest loan strategy.